The “lost” Shemelds of Skelton

I guess most genealogists have the same buried deep in their family tree. An ancestor or two whose name you recognise, however you can’t quite place them within your ancestral tree without checking your records. They are normally found after following a few right turns (i.e up the maternal branches of your tree, where surnames tend to change from generation to generation). Recently I’ve been researching one of these branches, the Shemelds of Skelton, and I think I’ve become quite attached to them.

One of the most appealing features of the Shemelds is their unusual surname. Normally this a genealogist’s dream. It’s much easier to track down a rare surname like Shemelds than trying to figure out your Smiths and Jones (or your Müller, Meier, Schulze as they are known in German). Sadly the Shemelds suffered from two handicaps.

  1. The name can be easily mis-understood. You can pretty much use all five vowels in the surname if you are feeling up to it. Combine this with the option to ignore the final S in their name, then you can come up with some creative spelling.
  2. They lived in a very small village. I think it’s safe to assume that the curates responsible for maintaining the Parish Registers in Skelton weren’t “the sharpest tool in the box“. As a result they weren’t going to be too precise in recording the lives of their Shemelds parishioners.

Looking through my research notes I have around 10 different spellings amongst the 40- odd local records I’ve found, ranging all the way from Shimmels to Chimmelds. Sadly this wonderful surname has now disappeared and doesn’t even appear on my favourite British names-profiling website. This is inevitable with surnames, especially uncommon ones. Someday I’m planning to write a short surname simulator to show how this happens.

Before they disappear totally from history I want to write up my research. My connection with the Shemelds is through Mary Shemelds (b.1770, d.1836). This is her baptism record in the Skelton Parish Registers:

I think she's a Chimmolds, daughter of Thomas, a Taylor by trade

I think she’s a Chimmolds, daughter of Thomas, a Taylor by trade

She’s the daughter of Thomas Shemelds, a taylor by profession, and Sarah Burton. They were married some 12 years earlier in the 30th April 1758, again in Skelton.

Looks like Thomas is a Shimmons in this one, unless you have a better suggestion.

Looks like Thomas is a Shimmons in this one, unless you have a better suggestion.

Thomas and Sarah had 5 children, Ann (b.1759), Mary (1761-1762), Thomas (1762-1841), Sarah (1765) and a second Mary (1770-1836). As you can see only a single son to carry on the family name. He did. Thomas (we’ll call him Thomas Jr. just to avoid confusion) married Elizabeth Wright on 13th Nov 1783. Their marriage is recorded in the “The Register Booke of Inglebye iuxta Grenhow” (originally transcribed by the local curate John Blackburne, but re-plublished by in 2014)

The Register Booke of Ingelbye Iuxta Grenhow

It looks like Elizabeth then joined Thomas Jr. in Skelton. They had 9 children together: William Shemelds (1784-1854), Mary Shemelds (b.1786), Thomas Shemelds (1788-1814), John Shemelds (1791-1812), Betty Shemelds (1793-1838), Esther Shemelds (1796-1828), Wright Shemelds (1798-1830), Anne Shemelds (b.1802), George Shemelds (b. 1805).

At this point the Shemelds begin to disappear from history. Marriage records for these Shemelds are scarce. William appears to have married three times between 1820 and 1833, all three times in Ingleby. It seems rather suspicious that he had 3 marriages in such quick succession. Did the wives die during childbirth ? Perhaps he was like Henry VIII and in desperate need of an heir ? Whatever the case, I can find no records of children. Some of the other children, including Esther were swept up in the religious fervour of their time. Here is part of her obituary from “The Wesleyan Methodist Magazine, Volume 8”

I have to say Esther made a dramatic exit from this life.

Of the other males in this generation, both John and Thomas (the third) died as relatively  young adults. Again I’ve no evidence that either of them married. This only leaves George Shemelds, the last of the Shemelds. Sadly I’ve yet to find any records of his life, so maybe he’s out there somewhere, waiting to be found.

Earlier Records

At the moment I haven’t managed to trace the Shemelds further back in time. There are records (and family trees) that list Shemelds living in nearby Marton-in-Cleveland (see map below). These include a Thomas Shimmells born 1737. This would fit with my known Thomas ancestor, however there is no evidence (such as a baptism record saying Thomas Shemelds native of Marton etc.) that this is correct. Maybe DNA testing may in future conform this link.

Final Thoughts

One of the reasons I’ve headed down this research path is that one of my four “DNA relatives” according to She is a descendant of Thomas Shemelds and Sarah Burton. To celebrate this I wanted to make sure my records of the Shemelds were as good as they could be. As an aside, I’ve checked on all three DNA sites and this person is indeed the only Shemelds descendant I can find (so far).

As far as I can determine this line of Shemelds has been lost to history, at least on the paternal line. The good news is that all three sisters of the Thomas Shemelds Jr. married and had children. So whilst the name and yDNA of Thomas Shemelds is lost to history there is much more hope that Sarah Burton’s Mitochondrial DNA is still with us today.

Sources and Records

Since this article is about the Shemelds I thought it worth pulling together all the information I have on them.

  •  The main source for any pre-1837 British records are the Parish Registers. Whilst you can look up the originals, held in the Teesside Archives, most people will find that it’s quicker and easier to The film number for the Bishop’s transcripts of the Skelton Parish Registers is 919077. Note: searching for the Shemelds is much simpler when you use “Wildcard” searches such as Shem* or Shim* for the surnames.
  • As you may have guessed from the images on this blog, I’ve recently been looking at the microfilms of the Parish Registers at my local LDS Family History Centres.
  • The Skelton History Group is an excellent source of all things Skelton. As well as having their own copies of the Parish Registers they have records and plans of the Old All Saints Parish Church graveyard. This has been a real help in giving both dates of death and confirming family relationships.
  • There is an excellent website dedicated to the “Skelton-in-Cleveland in History” written by Bill Danby.
  • The Parish Registers for Great Ayton are available thanks to the work of Dan O’Sullivan and his team from “The Great Ayton Community Archaeology Project” .
  • Finally I’ve added below a spreadsheet of all local references to the Shemelds. It’s mostly taken from trawling the website. I have no claims on it’s completeness, but hopefully it’s a starting point for anyone else interested in the Shemelds.

[Update 2-Nov-2015]. Rather fittingly, since today is All Souls Day, I’ve found a couple more references to Shemelds, although in this case they are Shem(m)els. They are taken from the Parish Registers in Great Ayton. The most interesting is the marriage of Thomas Shemels to Jane Hebron on 12th June 1796. They are described as widower and widow, however the Thomas Shemelds fits neither Thomas Shemelds(d.1798), or Thomas Shemelds Jnr (1762-1841), as both had wives at the time. This is confirmed by their shared gravestone which show both had wives at the time. “In memory of Thomas Shemelds who died the 14th of January 1798 aged 60 years also Sarah his wife who died 18th of February 1805 aged 76 years Elizabeth the wife of Thomas Shemelds Jun. died 3rd June 1832 aged 71 years also Thomas Shemelds Jun. who died June 2nd 1841 aged 78 years“. I guess Thomas may somehow be related to the Shemmels of Marton.

This entry was posted in Genealogy, MyFamily and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to The “lost” Shemelds of Skelton

  1. Thanks for making the link between your site and ours; and thanks for the kind things you’ve said about our site.

    You might also be interested in the book ‘My Grandad was a “Felon”‘, written by our Secretary, Peter Appleton. It covers many aspects of the history of the community of Skelton between 1787 and 1973. Thomas Shemelds (1762-1841) was a member of Skelton Association for the Prosecution of Felons in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. Within it is a short biography of Thomas’ life, including his role in establishing the Methodist community in the village. More details about the book can be found on our Group’s website or via

  2. Simon John Shemelds Taylor says:

    I read the artcile above with interest and I am a direct decended of Mary Shemelds who married William Taylor. in Skelton in 1813.
    Since 1813 we have carried the Shemelds name with TAYLOR. I have past this Shemelds on to my 2 sons so whilst the surname of Shemelds disappears I hope the name can still be carried.
    All the best

  3. lizplummer says:

    There are quite a few Shemilts in Staffordshire, where my ancestors mostly came from; maybe this is another variation of the name.

    • Hi, apologies for the late reply, Easter was busy and the blog got a little left behind. Shemilts sounds as though it belongs to the same family of surnames. I wonder if they are all related, or if the surname is based on an occupation ?

  4. Karen says:

    Thomas Shemelds Taylor, who was Lord Mayor of Hull, and Sherrif also, was my great-grandfather. I have some great photos of the family laundry business in Holderness Rd, Hull.
    I have a few family stories. E.g. My grandmother, Elizabeth (Poppy) maintained contact with her brother William who was in a relationship with a separated Catholic woman – not approved of by the Methodist family. I think the family sent him to Australia 🙂

    • Simon S J Taylor says:

      Hi Karen,

      Thomas Shemelds Taylor is my Great Grandfather too I am descended via his son John Wilfrid Taylor , Please feel free to contact would love to swop info.



  5. Josie Bland says:

    I’m a member of the Skelton History Group and would like to know exactly what the connection was between Skelton and Ingleby Greenhow. Your ancestor married there, my grandfather x4 and his wife lived in Ingleby for a few years, their two youngest children were baptised there yet he seems to still be a member of the Skelton Cburch Vestry whilst seemingly living in Ingleby. Its a real puzzle. I also found that a curate from Ingleby Greenhow had transcribed some of Skeltond Parish Registers? Any ideas??

    • Hi Josie, to be honest I’ve no idea what the connection one. It’s a bit of a hike to get from Ingleby Greenhow to Skelton. Stokesley would be the nearest market town for anyone in Ingleby, so I’m not sure why anyone from Ingleby would normally meet someone from Skelton. I can only guess that there were some family ties between the two villages. Sorry I can’t be more useful !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.